main@SIKM.groups.io

Re: Model of an intelligent knowledge extraction in organizations #extraction #definition

I support what both Fred and Chris write about tacit and implicit knowledge. I think it is possible to transfer tacit knowledge through observation of the expert, followed by in-depth

By Nancy Dixon · #8578 ·

Re: Model of an intelligent knowledge extraction in organizations #extraction #definition

OK Fred…that’s fine. Best Bill

By Bill Kaplan · #8577 ·

SIKM Peer Assist - Lessons Learned Delivery - January 25, 2021 #lessons-learned #peer-assist

The SIKM Community will host a peer assist call to help David Graffagna in the challenge he recently posted - Lessons Learned Storage & Access. It will be held on Monday, Jan 25 from 3-4:30 PM CST.

By Tom Barfield · #8576 · Edited

Re: Model of an intelligent knowledge extraction in organizations #extraction #definition

Good question. As I see it, once knowledge is elicited/codified, it is (by definition) information (e.g., in a database, report, etc.). It can then be converted back into (someone else’s)

By Tim Powell · #8575 ·

Re: Model of an intelligent knowledge extraction in organizations #extraction #definition

How is explicit knowledge information? We have information. But if we don't put it in a proper process and use it, it is not knowledge. It is useless. The information which is not used can't be

By Mila Malekolkalami · #8574 ·

Re: Model of an intelligent knowledge extraction in organizations #extraction #definition

I’m so glad, Bill, Chris, and Fred that you’ve mentioned that “explicit knowledge” is actually information. When I wrote this in my latest book, I predicted that it would be received in some

By Tim Powell · #8573 ·

Re: Model of an intelligent knowledge extraction in organizations #extraction #definition

I understand, Bill. I simply don’t agree with you. Fred Nickols

By Fred Nickols · #8572 ·

Re: Model of an intelligent knowledge extraction in organizations #extraction #definition

I agree, Chris. Explicit knowledge is knowledge that has been codified. It is indeed information. Fred Nickols

By Fred Nickols · #8571 ·

Re: Model of an intelligent knowledge extraction in organizations #extraction #definition

HI Chris I agree with explicit = information Bill

By Bill Kaplan · #8570 ·

Re: Model of an intelligent knowledge extraction in organizations #extraction #definition

I’m with you Fred. ...and from my perspective (which not everyone shares!), I would add that explicit knowledge = information. Cheers, Chris Get Outlook for iOS

By Chris Collison · #8569 ·

Re: Model of an intelligent knowledge extraction in organizations #extraction #definition

Hi Fred I say the following knowing the risk with which I am placing myself😊…never been a fan of “implicit” and so I am not a fan of Polanyi’s definition. My point, based on years of

By Bill Kaplan · #8568 ·

Re: Model of an intelligent knowledge extraction in organizations #extraction #definition

FWIW, in relation to Bill’s use of “explicit” and “tacit,” I find a third category useful; namely, “implicit.” I define “implicit” as knowledge which hasn’t been articulated but

By Fred Nickols · #8567 ·

Re: Lessons Learned Storage & Access #lessons-learned

Gabi, Most of what we have done with lessons learned to this point has been in the context getting to know our audiences (e.g., project team types), gathering input on any lessons learned approaches

By David Graffagna · #8566 ·

Re: Model of an intelligent knowledge extraction in organizations #extraction #definition

Bill, Well stated. However, it is nice to know that some non-IT approaches have emerged and been perfected. Some day, IT will no doubt be able to scan our brains, and retrieve all our knowledge,

By Douglas Weidner · #8565 ·

Re: Model of an intelligent knowledge extraction in organizations #extraction #definition

Dear Colleagues Been enjoying this timeless discussion on K capture and the extended inference about tacit knowledge and the subtleties of human language in the sharing in the context of the below

By Bill Kaplan · #8564 ·

Re: Model of an intelligent knowledge extraction in organizations #extraction #definition

Thank you all for your help. You helped me a lot to have a better view.

By Mila Malekolkalami · #8563 ·

Re: Model of an intelligent knowledge extraction in organizations #extraction #definition

I've actually had a couple of textual intelligent technologies articles so the work is progressing, but I agree it is young and not ready...murray jennex

By Murray Jennex · #8562 ·

Re: Model of an intelligent knowledge extraction in organizations #extraction #definition

We are still very far from seeing any AI technology that can intelligently extract human knowledge in a broad sense. A main challenge is that of data, and in particular textual data. Data has to be

By Sam Yip · #8561 ·

Re: Model of an intelligent knowledge extraction in organizations #extraction #definition

to be honest, while many are claiming to be doing both forms of knowledge I personally doubt it. I am having a difficult time seeing how the claims that AI can figure out the tacit knowledge being

By Murray Jennex · #8560 ·

Re: Model of an intelligent knowledge extraction in organizations #extraction #definition

Hi Mila, My view is that there are several interlocking strands to this topic that tend to get overpowered by the technologists (as Murray notes). I root the following analysis in:

By Stephen Bounds · #8559 ·

Messages